Injury compensation lawyer Maitland: threshold and beyond

In everyday speech, a serious injury is one that hurts a lot or takes a long time to heal. The CTP scheme uses narrower tests. The first is whether the injury is more than a threshold injury. The second, for some kinds of compensation, is how much permanent impairment it leaves, measured as whole person impairment. Pain matters to you, but the scheme looks at diagnosis and lasting effect.

People are often surprised by how technical WPI is. It is assessed under guidelines that rate specific impairments, such as lost movement in a joint, and express the result as a whole-body percentage. More than 10% is the key line in CTP claims, because damages for non-economic loss, meaning pain and suffering, are only available above it. Loss of earnings doesn't need that level.

Because so much can turn on a few percentage points, WPI assessments are often contested. Your treating doctors, the insurer's chosen doctor and, if there's a dispute, a medical assessor through the Personal Injury Commission may reach different figures. Keep every report, and get advice before accepting an assessment you think is wrong.

The scheme treats psychological injury seriously, but it still sorts it by diagnosis. A threshold psychological injury is generally handled like a threshold physical one. A more serious diagnosed condition may take the claim beyond the threshold. Because the difference turns on the diagnosis, the opinion of a treating psychiatrist or psychologist can matter a great deal.

Earning capacity compares what you could have earned without the injury with what you can realistically earn now. For a tradesperson with a damaged shoulder, or an office worker with a brain injury, that gap can be large and long-lasting. Record every change to your working life: hours, duties, roles you can no longer do. Those facts sit alongside the medical evidence.

From 1 April 2023, the scheme uses the term threshold injury, which replaced the old term minor injury. A threshold injury is generally a soft tissue injury, a threshold psychological injury, or both. Soft tissue here means muscles, tendons, ligaments and similar tissue. Nerve damage is excluded, and so is a full or partial tear of a tendon, ligament, meniscus or cartilage.

The line also decides whether common law damages are open. With only a threshold injury, they generally aren't. With a more serious injury, you may be able to claim damages if another driver was at fault and you weren't mostly at fault. That is why a threshold decision is often the most important decision the insurer makes about a serious injury.

In a serious injury claim, impairment often comes into focus well after the crash, once treatment has run its course. The Personal Injury Commission handles medical assessment where the insurer and the injured person disagree. If you think an assessment is wrong, the steps to challenge it are set out separately, and the deadlines are short, so act promptly.

• Whether every injured body part is included
• Changes in your condition since the last report
• Whether you disagree with the result, and the deadline to say so

Because serious injuries take time to show their full effect, evidence builds in layers. Early records show the injury happened and how bad it was. Later reports show how it has settled and what it has left behind. An independent lawyer can help spot gaps, but the underlying evidence comes from your treatment. Getting good care is also how good evidence is made.

• Hospital admission and discharge records
• Imaging reports, such as X-ray, CT or MRI, where done
• Operation and specialist reports
• Any impairment assessment, and your response to it