CTP Claims

Threshold Injury Disputes: Challenging a 'Minor Injury' Decision

Whether your injury is a threshold injury is one of the most important decisions in a NSW CTP claim. It decides how long benefits last and whether damages are possible. And it can be challenged.

Last updated · General information, not legal advice

In short

  • From 1 April 2023, 'minor injury' was renamed 'threshold injury'.
  • A threshold injury is generally a soft tissue injury or a threshold psychological injury.
  • For accidents from 1 April 2023, threshold injuries generally get statutory benefits for up to 52 weeks, and no damages claim.
  • Nerve damage and full or partial tears of a tendon, ligament, meniscus or cartilage are generally not threshold injuries.

What a threshold injury is

From 1 April 2023, the term 'minor injury' was replaced by 'threshold injury'. You will still see 'minor injury' in older letters, and it applies to accidents before that date. A threshold injury is generally a soft tissue injury, for example to muscles, tendons or ligaments, and/or a threshold psychological injury.

Some injuries are generally not soft tissue injuries for these purposes, even though they involve soft tissue. These include nerve damage and a full or partial tear of a tendon, ligament, meniscus or cartilage.

Psychological injuries are assessed separately. Some short-term psychological reactions are treated as threshold psychological injuries, while more serious diagnosed conditions may not be. How the condition is diagnosed and documented matters a great deal.

Why the classification matters so much

In practical terms, the same whiplash-type injury can lead to a 52-week claim or to a longer claim with a damages component, depending on what the evidence shows. See minor vs non-minor injury.

  • Benefit period: for accidents on or after 1 April 2023, people with a threshold injury can receive statutory benefits for up to 52 weeks. For accidents from 1 December 2017 to 31 March 2023, the limit for minor injuries was generally 26 weeks.
  • Damages: you can only claim common law damages if your injury is more than a threshold injury.
  • Treatment: for threshold injuries, treatment beyond the benefit period may sometimes be allowed, but only in limited circumstances.

Where disputes usually arise

  • Neck or back injuries with symptoms radiating into an arm or leg, which may suggest nerve involvement.
  • Scans showing a partial tear that the insurer has treated as a sprain or strain.
  • Shoulder or knee injuries where a tear of a tendon, ligament or meniscus is suspected but hasn't been investigated.
  • Psychological injuries that haven't yet been formally assessed.
  • Decisions made early, before scans, specialist opinions or nerve studies were done.

How to challenge a threshold injury decision

Start with an internal review by the insurer, generally within 28 days of receiving the decision. If the decision stands, the dispute can go to the Personal Injury Commission for a medical assessment by an independent medical assessor. A review of a medical assessment certificate must generally be sought within 28 days of the certificate being issued.

Two people going through a bound document together, one pointing at a clause

Claim denied or cut off?

Work out your options after a refusal

Most insurer decisions can be reviewed, but you generally need to ask for an internal review within 28 days. A few questions and we'll explain the general next steps.

Internal review and the Personal Injury CommissionTime limits explainedGeneral information, not advice

The claim check looks at where your claim is up to and, if your case calls for it, connects you with an independent CTP lawyer. Many claims never need one, and we'll tell you if yours doesn't.

The evidence that helps

Threshold disputes are decided on evidence that addresses the legal definition, not just the symptoms. Evidence that commonly helps includes:

  • Imaging that identifies any tear or structural damage.
  • Test results or findings that show nerve damage, where it's suspected.
  • A report that addresses the legal definition directly, not just the symptoms.
  • A formal diagnosis for any psychological injury.
  • Consistent records from the start of the claim.

Don't let the 52-week mark sneak up

If you have a threshold injury decision and your benefits are approaching the 52-week mark, the timing matters. Challenging the decision early gives you the best chance of avoiding a gap in benefits, and keeps a possible damages claim alive.

When to talk to a lawyer

Because this decision controls access to damages, it is one of the most common reasons people speak to a CTP lawyer. See CTP dispute lawyer for how we connect people with one. Talk to a lawyer if:

  • The evidence suggests your injury is more than a soft tissue injury.
  • You have symptoms such as pins and needles, numbness or weakness, or scans showing a tear.
  • You have a diagnosed psychological condition that the insurer has treated as threshold.
  • Your benefits are about to stop and you believe the classification is wrong.
Two people talking through paperwork across a desk in a bright office

Free claim check

Get your CTP claim checked

Denied, cut off, disputed, or just not sure what you're entitled to? Tell us what's happened and we'll talk it through in plain English.

  • We look at where your claim is up to — the insurer's decisions, the time limits, and what's in dispute.
  • If your case calls for a lawyer, we can connect you with an independent specialist CTP lawyer. You choose whether to go ahead.
  • We explain the time limits that may apply to you — such as the window to ask for an internal review — and which are close.
  • Free, with no obligation. Many claims never need a lawyer — if yours doesn't, we'll tell you.
Your details
Your claim

Free · No obligation · Not a law firm

General information about the NSW CTP scheme, not legal advice. Time limits apply, so get advice about your own situation. CTP Lawyer is not a law firm. When a claim calls for it, we connect people with independent CTP lawyers. Official detail: SIRA motor accidents. Free CTP information: CTP Assist on 1300 656 919.

FAQs

Related

Keep reading

A woman on a phone call, listening intently

Free claim check

Not sure where your claim stands?

Tell us what happened and we'll explain your options in plain English, then tell you whether your case calls for an independent CTP lawyer and connect you with one if it does. Free, with no obligation.

Call now — (02) 7238 7379Free claim check