Eastern Suburbs · CTP claim denied

Insurer said no? CTP dispute options in St Pauls

The insurer's decision is rarely the last word. The first deadline is generally 28 days, so start now.

Free claim check

Your details
Your claim

Free · No obligation · Not a law firm

A letter refusing your CTP claim can feel final. It usually isn't. Most insurer decisions can be challenged, first by internal review and then at the Personal Injury Commission. If you live in St Pauls and the insurer has said no, our free claim check looks at the decision and its deadlines, and connects you with an independent CTP lawyer if a dispute is worth pursuing. Some aren't, and we'll tell you.

  • Free claim check, no obligation
  • By phone & online, no office to visit
  • Helping people in St Pauls & Randwick

What a review looks like from St Pauls

If a crash on Anzac Parade or New South Head Road led to a refusal, read the decision letter for the reasons it gives. Your internal review request should answer those reasons directly, point by point. People in St Pauls, within Randwick City Council, follow the same dispute path as everyone else in NSW: internal review first, generally within 28 days, then the Personal Injury Commission. Where you live doesn't change the deadlines. St Pauls is about 3 km south of Bondi Junction, but challenging a decision doesn't mean travelling there. Internal reviews are generally requested in writing, and our claim check runs by phone and online.

Region
Eastern Suburbs
Postcode
2031
Local government area
Randwick City Council
Distance to Bondi Junction
~3 km

You can ask for a second look

Insurers make decisions under the scheme rules: whether to accept a claim, how much to pay, which benefits to approve, whether an injury is threshold. Most of them can be challenged. The first step is an internal review, which you generally need to request within 28 days of the decision reaching you. If that doesn't resolve it, the Personal Injury Commission can decide.

Read next:CTP claim denied?

When your issue is how you were treated

A dispute is about a decision, such as whether your claim is accepted. A complaint is about conduct, such as delays, unanswered calls or unclear letters. Complaints about the conduct of CTP insurers go to the Independent Review Office (IRO) on 13 94 76, 8:30am to 5:30pm weekdays, or online at iro.nsw.gov.au. The IRO doesn't fund lawyers for CTP claims.

The decisions behind many disputes

Some decisions come up again and again. A claim may be refused because it was lodged late, or limited because the insurer says the injury is threshold or that you were mostly at fault. Weekly payments may stop, or a request for treatment and care may be declined. Each raises its own evidence questions, and each can generally be reviewed.

  • The claim was lodged late
  • The injury was classed as a threshold injury
  • You were found wholly or mostly at fault
  • Your pre-accident earnings were set lower than you expected

Read next:Claim denied? Quick check

Two people talking through paperwork across a desk in a bright office

Free claim check

Get a clear view of your dispute

The claim check is free and carries no obligation. Tell us what the insurer decided, and we'll point you to the right help.

Disputing a threshold-injury decision

A threshold decision limits statutory benefits to 52 weeks for accidents from 1 April 2023, and it rules out a damages claim. A threshold injury is generally soft tissue, and it doesn't include nerve damage or a full or partial tear of a tendon, ligament, meniscus or cartilage. If the evidence shows one of those, the classification may be wrong.

Read next:Threshold injury disputesWhen the insurer says “threshold injury”

Asking for an internal review

A good review request is short and specific. Quote the decision and its date. Explain in plain terms where you think the insurer got it wrong, with reference to the evidence. If there's something the insurer didn't have, such as a new report, include it. Keep a copy and note when you sent it.

Don't wait until the last days of the window to start. Reports and records can take time to arrive, and a rushed request is usually weaker. If some evidence won't be ready in time, lodge the request within the deadline anyway and tell the insurer what else is on its way.

The 28-day window

The review deadline is short: generally 28 days from receiving the decision. If you're unsure which date counts, work from the earlier one.

Read next:Insurer stopped my weekly payments

What the Commission does

The Personal Injury Commission, or PIC, is an independent tribunal that started on 1 March 2021. In the CTP scheme it handles merit review, medical assessment, miscellaneous claims assessment and claims assessment of damages claims. It replaced the older dispute bodies, so older material that sends you elsewhere is out of date.

Read next:The Personal Injury CommissionPIC disputes explained

What a dispute might cost

In a dispute about statutory benefits, legal costs work differently from what many people expect. Costs are recoverable only where the Regulation or the Personal Injury Commission allows, the insurer pays whatever is recoverable, and in some disputes nothing can be recovered at all. So before you engage a lawyer for a review, ask how their fees would work for this particular dispute, and get the answer in writing.

Read next:What does a CTP lawyer cost?

Your review path

Most CTP decisions follow the same review path. The deadlines are short, so it helps to know the order before you start. Complaints about how the insurer behaves are a separate track.

  1. Step 1

    Read the decision letter

    Note the date you received it, what was decided and the reasons given. The date matters, because the time to ask for a review generally runs from when you receive the decision.

  2. Within 28 days

    Ask for an internal review

    Request the review in writing, inside the 28-day window that generally applies. The insurer looks at the decision again, so explain clearly why you think it's wrong and attach anything it didn't have.

  3. 14 to 28 days

    The insurer decides

    The insurer usually has 14 days to decide the review. For some medical and miscellaneous matters it's 21 days, and up to 28 days if it needs more information from you.

  4. If you still disagree

    Apply to the Personal Injury Commission

    If internal review leaves the decision in place, the next step is generally an application to the Personal Injury Commission, an independent tribunal. What you're disputing decides which of its paths applies, such as merit review or medical assessment.

  5. 28 days from a certificate

    Medical assessment review

    Medical assessment certificates can generally be reviewed, but the window is short: generally 28 days from the date the certificate is issued. Get advice quickly if you're considering it.

  6. Any time

    Conduct complaints go to the IRO

    If your concern is how the insurer has treated you, such as delays or poor communication, that's a complaint, not a dispute. The Independent Review Office handles those complaints on 13 94 76.

General information, not legal advice. Timeframes are general, and some decisions follow different rules. Check your decision letter and get advice quickly.

When a dispute calls for legal help

Some reviews are simple: supply the missing evidence and ask again. Others turn on legal questions or high stakes. Here's a general guide to which is which.

Often worth talking to a lawyer

  • The dispute is heading to the Personal Injury Commission
  • The refusal is based on your claim being late
  • Weekly payments were stopped and you can't work
  • You've missed the review deadline

You may not need one

  • A request was declined only because some information was missing
  • The decision was about a small, one-off expense
  • You agree with the decision once it's explained

For statutory benefits disputes on accidents from 1 December 2017, SIRA's free CTP Legal Advisory Service can help before internal review starts. CTP Assist on 1300 656 919 can connect you with it. The Personal Injury Commission

Not quite your situation?

  • For the wider question of whether a lawyer is worth it on a CTP claim at all, the CTP lawyer page for St Pauls is the better fit. CTP lawyer in St Pauls
  • When the real argument is how serious your injury is, the injury compensation page for St Pauls covers impairment and the threshold line. Injury compensation lawyer in St Pauls
  • If you haven't had a decision yet and are still getting the claim in, start with the CTP claims page for St Pauls. CTP claims in St Pauls

Frequently asked questions

Ready to talk it through?

Get a free, no-obligation claim check. It's the first step toward understanding where your claim stands and what help it needs.

CTP Lawyer is not a law firm. This page is general information, not legal advice; the independent lawyer you speak with can advise on your own situation.

Call now — (02) 7238 7379Free claim check