Injuries

Shoulder Injury After a Car Accident

A shoulder strain and a rotator cuff tear are treated very differently under the CTP scheme — even though they can feel similar.

Last updated · General information, not legal advice

Understanding shoulder injury

Shoulder injuries from bracing against the wheel, a seatbelt or a side impact range from a soft tissue strain to a rotator cuff or labral tear. This is one of the clearer distinctions in the CTP threshold rules: a strain is generally a threshold injury, but a full or partial tendon, ligament or cartilage tear is specifically excluded from the threshold definition, so it's generally treated as non-threshold. The report that confirms whether there's a tear is often what settles which category your shoulder injury falls into.

Common claim issues

These are the points insurers and lawyers most often focus on with this kind of injury. Not every one will apply to your claim.

  • Strain or tear: the line that decides classification
  • A tear not yet confirmed when the insurer first decides
  • Degeneration argued as the cause instead of the crash
  • Lost earnings where reaching or lifting is part of your job
  • Whether whole person impairment is more than 10%

Free claim check

Not sure where this leaves your claim?

How we help

A free claim check can explain why the strain-versus-tear distinction matters so much for a shoulder claim, and what the insurer is likely to decide on the evidence so far. If a tear is confirmed, or the insurer is disputing the classification, we'll connect you with an independent lawyer who can make sure that evidence is properly used, including in any damages claim.

What you may be able to claim

A confirmed shoulder tear is generally not a threshold injury, so if you weren't wholly or mostly at fault, your statutory benefits aren't cut off at 52 weeks: weekly payments generally continue to 104 weeks, and longer while a damages claim is pending. If another driver was at fault, a common law damages claim can cover past and future loss of earnings, which matters if your work involves lifting or overhead tasks. A shoulder strain accepted as threshold is generally limited to 52 weeks of benefits for accidents from 1 April 2023, with no damages.

What you can claim under CTP

What matters for your claim

  1. 1If a tear is confirmed after the insurer's first decision, ask for the classification to be reconsidered
  2. 2Ask for an internal review within 28 days of any decision you disagree with
  3. 3Keep records of duties you can no longer do at work, and any change in hours or pay
  4. 4Whole person impairment is usually assessed once the shoulder has stabilised, which affects when a damages claim can resolve
  5. 5A damages claim generally can't settle within 2 years of the accident unless whole person impairment is more than 10%

Getting the right evidence

Shoulder claims often turn on one document: the report that confirms whether there's a tear. Make sure the injury is recorded early and linked to the accident, and keep every report and insurer decision. Keep your pay records and a note of the tasks you can't do.

This is general information, not legal or medical advice. Time limits apply, so get advice about your own situation.

Frequently asked questions

A woman on a phone call, listening intently

Free claim check

Get your CTP claim checked

Denied, cut off, disputed, or just not sure what you're entitled to? Tell us what's happened and we'll talk it through in plain English.

  • We look at where your claim is up to — the insurer's decisions, the time limits, and what's in dispute.
  • If your case calls for a lawyer, we can connect you with an independent specialist CTP lawyer. You choose whether to go ahead.
  • We explain the time limits that may apply to you — such as the window to ask for an internal review — and which are close.
  • Free, with no obligation. Many claims never need a lawyer — if yours doesn't, we'll tell you.
Your details
Your claim

Free · No obligation · Not a law firm

Call now — (02) 7238 7379Free claim check