Last updated · General information, not legal advice
Understanding knee injury
Knee injuries are common in car accidents, particularly from dashboard impact or bracing on the pedals just before a crash. As with shoulder injuries, the key legal distinction is between a soft tissue sprain (generally a threshold injury) and a meniscus, ACL or other ligament tear, which is specifically excluded from the threshold definition and so generally non-threshold. What the evidence confirms often decides which category applies, so don't assume the insurer's first view of your knee is the final one.
Common claim issues
These are the points insurers and lawyers most often focus on with this kind of injury. Not every one will apply to your claim.
- Sprain or tear: meniscus and ligament tears are generally non-threshold
- Age-related wear in the knee raised against the claim
- The effect on standing, kneeling and driving at work
- A threshold decision made before a tear was confirmed
- Whether damages for lost earnings are available
Free claim check
Not sure where this leaves your claim?
How we help
A free claim check can explain what your knee diagnosis is likely to mean for your claim, and whether the insurer's classification matches the evidence. If a tear is confirmed, or the insurer disputes the classification, we'll connect you with an independent lawyer who can help you pursue the right classification and, where appropriate, damages.
What you may be able to claim
A knee sprain accepted as threshold generally limits statutory benefits to 52 weeks for accidents from 1 April 2023 and rules out damages. A confirmed meniscus or ligament tear is generally non-threshold: if you weren't wholly or mostly at fault, weekly payments can continue beyond 52 weeks, and if another driver was at fault, a common law damages claim may cover lost earnings. Knee injuries often matter most for people whose work involves standing, climbing or kneeling, so the earnings side needs careful attention.
What you can claim under CTPWhat matters for your claim
- 1Keep a record of what you can't do: walking distance, stairs, kneeling and driving
- 2If a tear is confirmed after the insurer decided the injury was threshold, raise it and ask for a review
- 3Internal review requests are generally due within 28 days of receiving a decision
- 4The Personal Injury Commission can decide threshold disputes that aren't resolved at internal review
- 5Whole person impairment becomes relevant once the knee has stabilised, particularly for pain and suffering damages
Getting the right evidence
Knee classification usually comes down to whether a tear is recorded. Make sure the injury is recorded early and linked to the accident, and keep each scan report and insurer decision. Evidence of your duties at work, such as a position description, helps show the effect on your earnings.
This is general information, not legal or medical advice. Time limits apply, so get advice about your own situation.

