Last updated · General information, not legal advice
Insurers make decisions on evidence. In a CTP claim, three kinds do most of the work: evidence about how the accident happened, which decides fault; evidence about what you earned and can earn now, which drives weekly payments and any damages; and the records of your injuries. A consistent file can be the difference between a claim that runs smoothly and a drawn-out dispute, however genuine your injury is.
Evidence about the accident and fault
- The police event number.
- Photos of the scene, the vehicles, the road layout, signs and sightlines, taken at the time.
- Dashcam or nearby CCTV footage. Ask for it early, because footage is often overwritten within days.
- Witness names and phone numbers.
- The other driver's name, registration and insurer details.
- A note, made soon after, of what happened and what was said at the scene.
Evidence about your earnings
- Payslips covering the period before the accident, not just the last one.
- A letter from each employer confirming your usual hours and pay.
- Tax returns, business activity statements and accounts if you're self-employed, or platform statements for gig work.
- Evidence of a job offer, promotion or pay rise that was already in place.
- Records of time off, reduced hours or changed duties since the accident.
Records of your injuries
For the injury side, the claim relies on records made at the time: your Certificates of Fitness and the records and reports about your injuries. Keep copies of what you're given, in date order. Early records matter most, because they link the injury to the accident.
Why consistency matters more than volume
A large file with contradictory entries can work against you. Insurers and assessors look for a coherent story: an accident that's clearly described, an injury recorded early with a plausible link to the crash, and earnings that add up across payslips, tax records and what you told the insurer. Unexplained changes invite the kind of scrutiny that slows a claim down.
If your evidence has gaps
It's common for early records to be thin, especially if you didn't realise at the time how significant an injury was, or didn't think to keep payslips. A gap doesn't sink a claim on its own. Fill what you can now, explain the rest honestly, and expect the insurer to ask about it.
How this connects to disputes and damages
The same evidence that supports a smooth statutory benefits claim is usually the foundation for a whole person impairment assessment and, where you're eligible, a common law damages claim. Building a solid file early is one of the most practical things you can do for every stage of your claim that follows.
A simple way to organise your evidence
A chronological file — whether a physical folder or a dedicated folder on your phone or computer — makes an enormous difference when an insurer, an assessor or a lawyer needs to understand your history quickly. Group documents by type (the accident and police, insurer letters, earnings, certificates and injury records) and note the date on anything that isn't already clearly dated. It sounds basic, but a well-organised file is one of the simplest things you can do to help your own claim.
Don't wait for the insurer to ask
It's tempting to only send evidence when specifically requested, but proactively providing relevant new evidence as it becomes available — a new report, updated earnings, a change in your work — can prevent delays that come from the insurer not yet knowing something has changed. When in doubt about whether something is relevant, sending it with a brief covering note rarely hurts.
When evidence problems are worth advice
If a decision has gone against you because the insurer says something isn't proven, whether fault, earnings or injury, that's often where a lawyer helps most: working out exactly what's missing, and getting it in before a review deadline passes. Our guide to whether you need a lawyer covers the signs.

Not sure you need a lawyer?
Check whether a lawyer is likely to help
Answer a few questions about where your claim is up to and we'll point you to a sensible next step — including when you can probably manage without a lawyer.
The claim check looks at where your claim is up to and, if your case calls for it, connects you with an independent CTP lawyer. Many claims never need one, and we'll tell you if yours doesn't.
This is general information about the NSW CTP scheme, not legal advice. Time limits apply, and rules change, so get advice about your own situation. Official detail: SIRA motor accidents. CTP Assist: 1300 656 919.
FAQs
Related pages
Certificate of Fitness and your claim
Why this form carries weight with insurers, and how it affects weekly payments.
Read moreSelf-employed and gig workers
How weekly payments work without a regular payslip, and the evidence that helps.
Read moreIndependent medical examinations
What an IME is, why insurers arrange them, and your rights around the appointment.
Read moreWhole person impairment (WPI)
How impairment is assessed, and why the 10% line matters so much for damages.
Read moreThreshold injury disputes
What the 'minor injury' label limits, and how the insurer's decision can be challenged.
Read more

